Review: A Soul as Cold as Frost by Jennifer Kropf

Review: A Soul as Cold as Frost by Jennifer Kropf

A Lamp Post Parcel Book Review

    A Soul as Cold as Frost



   Book Category: YA fantasy 
   Recommendation based on likability/story:  4 ⭐
   Age recommendation: 12+ 

 Story Synopsis


A whimsical winter fantasy, perfect for readers looking for a cozy read with a bit of action, for the winter season.

 

🎶Listen to our hand-curated playlist, specifically designed to pair with this book! 


“Merry Christmas to all! And to all a good fright...


After an eccentric girl opens Helen's eyes to let her see the realm of Winter—a world with intersects tucked carefully into the cracks of our own, where monarchs have risen and fallen, it's forbidden to mention the name of The Dead King, and the currency is gold rings—Helen discovers things are far from ordinary in Winter. After trying to deny the existence of a disrupting train horn ringing in her ears for days, Helen receives a mysterious summons from a group who call themselves “The Crimson Court” to enter into The Quarrel of Sword and Bone—a traditional duel performed before one thousand witnesses that leaves only one survivor—and she’s forced to finally pay attention to the handsome boy who's been following her around with a warning on his tongue.


When the arrival of wicked villains propels Helen into the heart of Winter where there’s no going back, she finds herself being pursued by something else too – an ancient Truth that breathes living words of wisdom – the very wisdom forgotten by the Rime Folk when their disunity drove them to draw lines in the snow in an age of the past.


Helen must find a way out, or she’ll be dragged into the arena to face the crooked Queen head on before a crowd ready to watch her die.


The Winter Souls Series blends action and warm Christmas traditions, bringing the old forgotten tales of the season to life with new and grittier versions of famous characters out of old holiday legends, folklore, and myths; such as St. Nicholas, the Snow Queen, the Scrooge, and the Nutcracker.”

Why we love A Soul as Cold as Frost: 
❄️ Relatable Characters 
❄️ Close friendships
❄️ Cozy scenes that include hot cocoa and tales next to the crackling fireplace! 
❄️ Narnia winter vibes 
❄️ Good VS Evil 
❄️ Wholesome Christian Allegory

 


Likes:


The cozy snowy setting: When we first jump into the story, we meet Helen downtown, with all the cozy shops and bakeries lining the snowy sidewalks. We weren’t given all the answers to Helen and her background right away…instead, Helen is thrown into some peculiar situation. It makes the story interesting right away. I was intrigued as soon as I read Chapter 1.


The lyrical writing: The lyrical writing and scenes that described the winter atmosphere, and the food… it made it every bit more immersive, and I must say it was quite enjoyable:


“Liquid chocolate, melted onto my tongue, running into all the crevices and bursting into a rainbow of flavors. Dark chocolate beans with sweet spices, hence the sugary, orange, and creamy licorice.”
{Chapter 39, p. 371}

See what I mean?! Beautiful! 


Wholesome messages: There’s also some light Christian allegory sprinkled throughout:


“He spoke of a dazzling star that once burned across the skies of Winter; a sign to the Rime Folk that the Truth was near.”

“It’s better to fight alone in the daylight with Elowin at your side than to fight in the dark with a thousand soldiers at your side.”

“A word was etched into the pendant: SHAMMAH.
‘What’s shammah?’ I asked, my thumb running along the smooth surface. ‘It means you’re never alone. That the Truth stays with you.’”
“I realized he was telling me that the Truth stays with us, deep in our chests. Even when we turn our backs on it, it waits for us to come back.”

I appreciate that it is creatively woven into the story in a way that makes sense and isn’t random. I also appreciate that it’s not preachy. It’s not overly noticeable, but the themes are there. The way it’s depicted gives off C.S Lewis vibes, which I love! 


The pacing: This fantasy has a good mix of action (there are gnome battles with armour, bows, and - spoons? I guess you have to be resourceful sometimes!), fast-paced escape scenes, and balanced with cozy whimsicality.

Some of the scenes just make you want to snuggle up with a warm blanket, light a candle, and drink a hot cup of tea (or cocoa). IT’S PERFECT! There were many parts that had my interest held captive in its grip. I powered through this book!


The friendly banter: Oh, how I do love some good humor. Especially between siblings or friends. The banter between the FMC (female main character) and the MMC (male main character) is great. It’s the funny, friendly poking type of and humor, all playful jesting. 


    Dislikes: 


Passive character at times: I do like the FMC overall, but at times she seemed much too passive. Blurred spoiler below:

When her friend is taken by the bad guys, the FMC hides and runs away. Ok, well, her friend did tell her to run…but still! She was a little too impulsive. However, after she kind of abandons him to hide, the gnawing of her conscience starts getting at her. So she does go back looking for her friend pretty soon after she ran to get away. It was sweet to see how determined she was to help him escape his fate if he was left in the hands of the enemy…she didn’t immediately take no for an answer when one method (or person) seemed to make it more difficult.


The imperativeness of the FMC’s role: I wish we were shown a bit more as to why it was so important that the FMC in particular needed to be the Carrier of the orb. The story was entirely enjoyable and it made sense, but I wish that the need for the FMC to be the Carrier of the orb was somehow made more crucial to her but also those around her.


Unrealistic preparation for the duel: I wished that the FMC would’ve been more realistic and actually taken the time to train for the duel that was scheduled.

 

She knew very well that the duel would be in a few days, and she didn’t train for it at all. I wished that her friend would’ve helped her prepare better ahead of time since he knew the rules of the duel.

 

Content Warning Section 


 


Language: Little to none. “Bloody” as a British slang is used here and there throughout the book. “Frostbite” is used as a slang here and there. “Ragnashuck”, a made-up slang, is used throughout the book. “Dummy” used to name call and “stupid” is used a few times to describe a situation or idea.


Violence/graphic: There are a few fantasy battles, but no graphic violence is present. Brief mentions of blood. The most intense it gets:

 

"The ghostly creatures tossed Lucas’s crumpled form at the foot of the stairs to
the platform. His dark outfit shifted against the snow as he lifted his head to look
upon her, a swollen ring over his left eye making a pink cushion around the
topaz, and a splatter of fresh blood moistened his cheek from a puncture in his bottom lip". (Chapter 37, p. 397)


Romance/sexual: None. Only mention of hand-holding (or gripping the elbow) as the characters run away from bad guys, and holding on to each other as they jump over a cliff: 

"I put my hands on my hips and dropped my head, waiting for another argument, but to my surprise Wren put one of his ape-arms around my waist and yanked me to the edge. His chest muscles crowded me when he took in a deep breath. ‘This is a stupid idea.’ His grumble got swallowed when he jumped. My breath hitched, and a squeak broke through the walls of rushing air." (Chapter 24, p. 273)



MMC carried her when the FMC fainted. MMC puts his jacket over FMC’s shoulders as he passes her when he notices she’s cold. Brief and minor flirting (1x):

"His stare fell on the extra jacket around me. 'You got enough room in there for me too, Trite?' Lucas’s teeth flashed as he grinned." (Chapter 36, p 379)


Other:  Helen lives with her grandmother. Very brief explanation that her father left when she was little and her mother had died. Once the FMC compares herself to how her father left their family (Chapter 35, p. 337).

A brief scene shows how FMC’s father left when she was little, without really saying goodbye (Chapter 39, p. 412-413); the story never lingers on that aspect for long and is not a main theme.
There’s a scene where the FMC very briefly converses with a crystal gazer, but it is looked down upon by her friend and is not praised (Chapter 15, p. 198).

The main evil character is a witch. There is no demonic depicted witchcraft; rather, it’s similar to C.S Lewis’s White Witch figure. A brief explanation is given that “a dark spirit which lives below Winter gives her the magic”. Mention of prayer (1x) and the Truth (God) throughout.



Summary

I’m happy that I can say that I could read this book without any worries. It was clean while maintaining the realness of the situation. Romance was not a focus; 99.9% of it was sweet, close friendships. Any traces of romance in this book couldn’t even be categorized as a subplot, as there is so little. There was no graphic violence or weird messages. I was sad when I finished the book - I want to know where Helen goes after this! 

You’ll want a warm blanket, and a cup of tea or hot cocoa to go with this book! Happy reading! 📚✨



NOTE:
 In the following books, the friendship between the FMC (Helen) and the MMC (Zane) starts to grow a little. There were 1-2 moments in this book that may have hinted at that (though all was clean); for instance, when the FMC and her friend are in town that is jam-packed with people, she gets bumped off balance by a passing stranger, and the MMC overreacts, being slightly protective (which was really sweet, but not entirely necessary).

The series is known to be very clean and any romance is not explicit, only sweet (not descriptive or spicy romance)

 

 

 

Back to blog

1 comment

This is a well thought out and written review! Thank you so much!

Mark

Leave a comment