Review: Echo North by Joanna Meyer

Review: Echo North by Joanna Meyer

A Lamp Post Parcel Book Review

  Echo North 



   Book Category: YA Fantasy Romance. 
   Recommendation based on likability/story: 4.5 stars ⭐
   Age recommendation: 13-14+



 Story Synopsis

  A cozy winter read with a magical library, beauty and the beast vibes, dipped in scandinavian folklore.

 

This story is about a girl named Echo. She lives with her father (whom she is very close with), brother, and stepmother. Whilst wandering in the forest as a child, Echo made an attempt to help free a wolf from a trap, and her face was attacked. The scars on her face never let her forget how different she looked and was treated, compared to everyone else in the town. And her unkind stepmother certainly didn’t help.

Echo ends up working in her father’s bookshop, the books and cobwebs her sole company (aside from the odd customer here and there). She dreams of attending the university to become a doctor, but is dismayed and hurt when she gets into a disagreement with her stepmother and Echo’s application letter gets tossed into the fireplace.

One blizzard-y winter day, Echo stumbles upon a wolf in the forest - the same one who attacked her face when she was a child. It turns out he can talk, and he strikes a bargain with her, in order for her to save her father who is in trouble. Amidst Echo’s confusion and panic, the wolf’s bargain seems to be the only way to save her dear father. The bargain is sealed, and now it must be fulfilled. Echo is bound to her agreement, and if she tries to escape, well…there would not only be the wolf to reckon with, but the forest. Echo must live with the wolf in his manor within the deep forest for a full year.  The house always needs a keeper…

 Likes: 

 

The library/book mirrors: the descriptions were so beautiful and whimsical, it made me want to jump into the book! The idea of a magical library full of mirrors that act as portals into stories…ahhh I love!

The beautiful nature scenes: The way in which Meyer describes some of the scenes is so beautiful! It feels so immersive if you take an afternoon stroll through the forest while there’s a light drizzle! 

 

The wood is quiet as we walk, but not like before. There are birds singing in the trees, a flash of a deer’s white tail, a squirrel nibbling a nut on a fallen oak. The red flowers are gone. In their place grow tangles of honeysuckle and peonies and twists of wild roses, and they make the wood smell sweet. A track still winds between the trees, but it’s no longer paved with stones.
{Chapter 39, p. 371}



We stand in a quiet patch of forest, overshadowed by stars.
{Chapter 38, p. 366}

 

See? What did I tell you. OH – and the mirror book library!!

 

I stood in a huge, airy room. High paneled ceilings stretched twenty feet or more above my head, illuminated by a dozen sparkling chandeliers.
{Chapter 8, p 73}

 

The wood is quiet as we walk, but not like before. There are birds singing in the trees, a flash of a deer’s white tail, a squirrel nibbling a nut on a fallen oak. The red flowers are gone. In their place grow tangles of honeysuckle and peonies and twists of wild roses, and they make the wood smell sweet. A track still winds between the trees, but it’s no longer paved with stones.
{Chapter 39, p. 371}
I noticed that every mirror had a little gold description plate…book spines – they reminded me of book spines. I peered at a few of the description plates, which said things like: The Doorway to All Things: In Which a Magical Hat Causes Much Havoc. {Chapter --, p.--}



Beautiful. Just beautiful.

The mirror-book adventures: I can’t describe too much, or I’ll spoil it! But I loved the whimsical adventures Echo and Hal had inside the mirror-books! It made me want to get up and go with them! Echo could literally step into a mirror and into a completely different world of fantasy. If you’ve ever read or watched The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe, chances are we both can’t deny the fact that the thought had crossed both our minds to try. Or at least, imagine. Anyhoo, the mirror-book adventures sounded so…adventurous! I just love that this particular aspect reminds me so much of C.S Lewis’s The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe! 

    Dislikes: 

 

The odd timeline: There were a few points in the book where the timeline felt a little jarring. In the beginning, the pace is quite quick as we’re introduced to the characters. I didn’t get to build much of a strong bond or connection to the characters, and I found Echo’s character to be a bit shallow in the beginning. 

 

The character relationships: In the beginning of the book, we are told that Echo and her father are very close, we are never shown how close they are. I wish we would’ve seen some glimpses of close, sweet father-daughter moments or conversations. The only instance we are really given a glimpse of this is

when Echo runs back home after her face gets attacked by the wolf, and she cries into her father’s arms as he strokes her hair.

The author never makes us truly care for Echo’s father or their supposedly close relationship.

So when her father is found half-frozen in the forest, Echo may have been distressed, but as the reader, we’re not made to care for him very much (I know, so heartless). Months into Echo being at the wolf's house, it seems like she isn’t very occupied at all, being upset about how her father recovered and is getting on in life.

 

The depth of Echo and Hal’s relationship: As we walk through the story, Echo and Hal’s relationship starts to blossom into more than mere friendship (rather quickly, I might say…maybe they were both bored). Their feelings grow for each other, but I find them void of any real depth. There are no internal conflicts that bring them together really. Blurred spoiler below:

Other than the fact that Hal secretly needs Echo to break his curse. But we weren't told that until the last bit of the book.

 

Content Warning Section 

Including spoiler excerpts for parent's further wished discretion.

 

Insert our visual rating system here.

 

Language: “Devil’s child” is used a few times as an insult. “She sold her soul to the Devil” (1x). Mention of one aching for the other here and there.

Violence/graphic: Little to none. Brief mention of a wolf ripping out the throat of an animal as it eats. There is a brief scene that mentions that there’s blood dripping from the wolf queen's teeth. Blurred spoiler below: 

"And then the Wolf Queen is there, blood dripping from her teeth." Chapter 31, p. 295.

 

Mention of FMC and her guide having to kill their horses on a blizzard-y mountain, lest they and the horses die of hunger. 

Romance/sexual: Light romance. Mentions of close proximity here and there. Blurred spoilers below: 

"Hal wraps himself around me, presses my head against his chest." Chapter 38, p. 366.

"He lifts his free hand to cradle my chin in his palm." Chapter 39, p. 579.


Handholding, and light kisses (none of the above descriptive). Blurred spoilers below: 

"And then I'm leaning into him, pressing my lips against his. Kissing Hal, who was twice a wolf in the middle of a dying world. He pulls me close and kisses me back." Chapter 38, p. 563

"His lips move against my hair. 'I love you Echo.' I pull my face to his and kiss him as the lake laps quietly at the shore and the moon peeks silver over the horizon. His mouth is warm on mine, his fingers smooth against my jaw. He tastes like springtime, like promises." Chapter 39, p. 381

 

 Summary


I loved the cozy library aspect of this book. My favorite thing was finding a cozy space to sit with a warm blanket, and a candle to accompany my reading. And of course, a hot cup of tea. Nothing is complete without a hot cup of tea.

The romance was light and sweet - no spice. I didn't have to sit on the edge of my seat in case there was anything inappropriate - it was nice n' clean. The story had light Beauty and The Beast vibes, but it wasn't a huge theme

 

(other than the fact that Hal was a wolf by day, and turned into his human form by night, subject by the curse the Wolf Queen cast on him).



Happy reading! 📚✨

 

Back to blog

Leave a comment